Wednesday, December 21, 2016


I love the music of Christmas. I could play it all year long if my husband didn't object. Those songs are so uplifting and beautiful that they make me feel good just to hear them, and you can’t help but sing along with them.

My dad always loved Christmas, and was a great practical jokester. He delighted in making phone calls to his grandchildren, pretending to be Santa. He’d call back later on for a rundown about what happened on our end—the looks, the comments, and the joy of getting a real live phone call from Santa! One of the traditions in our house was the box of chocolate covered cherries that was always under the tree for him from my mom, a reminder of hard Christmases in years past when that might have been the only gift she could afford. Another was that our house was always filled with Christmas music.

I was a classically trained pianist from the time I turned seven years old. My father’s favorite Christmas carol was What Child Is This? Once I mastered it, I delighted in playing it for him because he took such pleasure in it, and since it was also the tune to another song, Greensleeves, I played it all year round for him. He'd sit in his easy chair and "direct" as I played it, then say, "I believe I need to hear that one again..."

The tune known as Greensleeves was a British drinking song for many years, a popular folk song that was not religious. In ancient Britain, there have been more than twenty different known lyrics associated with the tune throughout history. It was first published in 1652.

Shakespeare mentions it by name in “The Merry Wives of Windsor” in which it is played while traitors are hanged. It has been attributed to King Henry VIII, and said that he wrote it for Anne Boleyn. How did this song become one of the best-loved Christmas carols of all time?

In 1865, Englishman William Chatterton Dix wrote “The Manger Throne,” three verses of which became “What Child Is This?” During that particular era, Christmas was not as openly celebrated as it is today. Many conservative Puritan churches forbade gift-giving, decorating or even acknowledging the day as a special day for fear that Christmas would become a day of pagan rituals more than a serious time of worship. Although Dix wrote other hymns, in the context of the times, it was unusual for him to write about Christ’s birth, since many hymn writers and religious factions ignored Christmas completely.

The words represent a unique view of Christ’s birth. While the baby was the focal point of the song, the point of view of the writer seemed to be that of a confused observer. Dix imagined the visitors to the manger bed wondering about the child who had just been born. In each verse, he described the child’s birth, life, death and resurrection, answering the question with a triumphant declaration of the infant’s divinity.

“The Manger Throne” was published in England just as the U.S. Civil War was ending. The song quickly made its way from Britain to the United States. Dix died in 1898, living long enough to see “The Manger Throne” become the Christmas carol “What Child Is This?”

What's your favorite Christmas carol? Mine is SILENT NIGHT, but truly, I think they're all beautiful.

I hope you all have a very blessed Christmas and a wonderful 2014! MERRY CHRISTMAS!


  1. Merry Christmas to you and your family! Thanks for the fine post with the history of the song.

    1. Thanks, Oscar! I've always loved this song, probably because it was one of my dad's favorites and has sweet memories connected with it.

      I hope you and yours have a wonderful Christmas, too!

  2. My father also loved to have me play the piano. His favorite, "Autumn Leaves". When I would want to play at 2am he would try to complain, but I think he just enjoyed music.

    If I had to pick a favorite song, I don't think I could, but I do love the Bing Crosby, David Bowie duet. I can't get enough of that one. Doris

    1. Oh, I loved playing Autumn Leaves, too, Doris! I always liked playing in the early morning hours, too. I wonder why that was? My piano was on the opposite end of the house from the bedrooms, but they could still hear it, of course.

      I love that Bing Crosby/David Bowie duet, too. Hope you have a wonderful, wonderful Christmas!

  3. I didn't know Greensleeves and What Child is This had the same tune. Glad to learn something. I, too, love most of the Christmas songs, but in recent years I especially like the song, Mary Did you Know? Merry Christmas.

    1. Oh, Agnes, I love Mary Did You Know? too. Someone posted a Youtube clip of the guy who wrote it singing it on FB, and he really was good--and had some wonderful backup singers to help him out, too. I like Pentatonix's version of it, too. MERRY CHRISTMAS!

  4. Cheryl,

    Nice article! (A woman of many talents---the piano!) Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, and HAPPY NEW YEAR TO ALL!!