Tuesday, September 22, 2026

Some thoughts on writing or judging the Western novel

Post by Doris McCraw

aka Angela Raines


Image property of Doris McCraw

I have been thinking about judging and/or writing historical novels.  Then, when looking at the rubrics, how would I use them in my writing? 


1.     Historical Authenticity & Research

o   Accurately portrays time period, geography, technology, language, and social norms

o   Real events, policies, or conflicts are woven in without info-dumping

o   Anachronisms are absent or extremely rare

2.     Sense of Place & Atmosphere

o   Making the landscape of the West vivid and integral to the story

o   Weather, terrain, and isolation: how it influences character choices and plot

o   Setting feels lived-in, realistic

3.     Character Depth & Transformation

o   Protagonists fit the moral, cultural, and emotional tensions of the era

o   Characters evolve in response to hardship, conflict, or love

o   Secondary characters are distinct and support the plot

4.     Conflict, Stakes & Plot Momentum

o   Central conflicts arise realistically from historical and personal pressures

o   Stakes feel real with consequences

o   Action, quiet moments, and reflection are balanced while keeping engagement

5.     Thematic Resonance & Emotional Impact

o   Explores Western themes like survival, land use, justice, identity, or change

o   Avoids clichés while still honoring the myth of the West

o   Leaves a lasting emotional or intellectual impression


Would you add or change anything above? I appreciate the feedback.

Image property of Doris McCraw


Until next time.

Stay safe - Doris

Angela Raines - Amazon

Doris A. McCraw - Amazon


 

No comments:

Post a Comment