Post by Doris McCraw
aka Angela Raines
 |
| Image property of Doris McCraw |
I have been thinking about writing historical novels, specifically Westerns. When I look at the judging rubrics, how should I use them in my writing? (Please note, this post has nothing to do with the current judging for the Peacemaker Awards)
1. Historical Authenticity & Research
o
Accurately portrays time period, geography,
technology, language, and social norms
o
Real events, policies, or conflicts are woven in without info-dumping
o
Anachronisms are absent or extremely rare
2. Sense
of Place & Atmosphere
o Making the landscape of the West vivid and integral
to the story
o Weather, terrain, and isolation: how it influences character choices and plot
o
Setting feels lived-in, realistic
3. Character
Depth & Transformation
o
Protagonists fit the moral, cultural, and
emotional tensions of the era
o
Characters evolve in response to
hardship, conflict, or love
o
Secondary characters are distinct and support the plot
4. Conflict,
Stakes & Plot Momentum
o
Central conflicts arise realistically from
historical and personal pressures
o
Stakes feel real with consequences
o
Action, quiet moments, and reflection are
balanced while keeping engagement
5. Thematic
Resonance & Emotional Impact
o
Explores Western themes like survival, land use, justice, identity, or change
o
Avoids clichés while still honoring
the myth of the West
o
Leaves a lasting emotional or intellectual
impression
Would you add or change anything above? I appreciate the feedback.
 |
| Image property of Doris McCraw |
Until next time.
Stay safe - Doris
I think that about does it so far as rubrics go. I can't see anything I'd change or do differently. Nice job of summing it all up for us.
ReplyDeleteThank you. I was trying to find a 'system' I could check my work against and this is what I'd come up with. Nice to know I was on the right path. Doris
DeleteI'll agree it's a nice rubric. Sadly with the rise of setups like Regal Quill Press (One unidentified person and an LLM publishing western fiction under a number of pseudonyms.) the chances of anyone actually making use of this and getting to publication is slim.
ReplyDelete